Moving to the Sunshine State: 5 Amazing Places to Eat in Islamorada, FL

Popularly known as a fishing capital, the charming village of Islamorada is a lot more. This Florida gem is teeming with life, excitement, art, and vibrant people. And while there are nearly a million things to do in Islamorada, nothing beats the culinary scene. Cuisines in this exuberant town range from the familiar and delicious to the new and refined. If you plan to move to Islamorada or even visit this charming town, here are five outstanding restaurants that will make you want to stay forever.

Mangrove Mike’s Café

If you are a homebuyer out on the Florida coast looking for a new home, what better way to kick off a day of house hunting than with a warm meal? After a long day looking at listings with Islamorada FL real estate experts The Florida Keys Sold Sisters, head to Mangrove Mike’s Café for delicious diner-inspired lunches and breakfast options. This 1998-established spot is famous for its homey, hearty foods, welcoming staff, and comfortable settings. Make sure you arrive early and try the California Chicken.

Bayside Gourmet

The Bayside Gourmet is an authentic Italian restaurant serving amazing food and breathtaking waterfront views. You can sit inside or outside in the warm Islamorada air and enjoy a wide range of seafood dishes and other cuisines. True to Florida’s culture, all the food is locally sourced and fresh. The meals can be a bit pricy, and you may need a reservation, but the hassle is worth it because the food is fantastic. And while everything on the menu is good, try the Shrimp di Pomodoro. 

Kaiyo Grill & Sushi Bar

Established in 2002, The Kaiyo Grill & Sushi Bar is a haven of Asian cuisine, warmth, and stunning décor. This Afro-fusion spot serves some of the best sushi dishes and Asian cuisine in the state. The Mount Fuji, for instance, is scallops, baked shrimp, crab, sweet sriracha, and ponzu mayo on a California roll. The restaurant also serves Crunchy Fried Fish Fingers, a timeless house-special hit with kids served with mango sauce and rice or French fries.

MEAT Eatery and Taproom

If you love hamburgers and other American fares, you will love the MEAT Eatery and Taproom. This establishment was opened in 2012 and serves some of the most delicious hamburgers in Florida alongside craft beers and creative slides. The meat is fresh, locally sourced, and made and served by amiable staff. If you are in the mood for something hearty, order the Inside-Out Juicy Lucy Burger, which is Angus with bacon, lettuce, tomatoes, American cheese, and pimento cheese.

Ciao Hound

If you are traveling with your family, the Ciao Hound is the place to eat. This family-friendly restaurant serves Italian cuisine and a wide range of fresh seafood dishes. The décor is warm and inviting, and the prices are pocket-friendly. If you enjoy a glass of wine with dinner, you will also love their white, red, and sparkling wine selection. The dish to try here is the flavorful Bistecca.

Explore Homes for Sale in Islamorada with The Florida Keys Sold Sisters

The culinary scene in Islamorada is to die for and a great way to introduce yourself to the tastes and sounds of the town. But if you wish to move here, the real exploration begins when you hire a realtor. Contact trusted and renowned real estate experts, The Florida Keys Sold Sisters, to review exclusive listings of homes for sale in Islamorada and find your dream home.

Jack Herold